6.52pm BST
Evening summary
- Boris Johnson will present his plan to begin easing lockdown measures on Sunday, with aspects to come into effect on Monday. The cabinet and Cobra will meet over the weekend to agree a plan before the prime minister makes the announcement; he will make a statement to the Commons on Monday. Also today, Nicola Sturgeon told Holyrood her government would start to lift restrictions “as soon as possible”, after the latest data showed coronavirus-related deaths in Scotland fell for the first time, and the Welsh government said it expected a “careful and cautious approach” to relaxing the lockdown from Westminster.
- Rishi Sunak is preparing to wind down the job retention scheme from July as the government plans to gradually remove lockdown measures. A decision is yet to be made, but the Treasury is understood to be examining several options for tapering the scheme, including cutting the 80% wage subsidy to 60% and lowering the £2,500 cap on monthly payments. Another option promoted by employers’ groups to allow furloughed staff to work, but with a smaller state subsidy, is also under consideration.
- The official UK coronavirus death toll passed 30,000 as another 649 fatalities were recorded. The new total of 30,076 represents the number of people who have tested positive for Covid-19 and died, so the true number will be much higher.
- Heathrow airport is to begin temperature screening of passengers in an effort to minimise transmission across borders. The airport’s chief executive, John Holland-Kaye, said it would trial technologies and processes that could form the basis of a common international standard for health screening at airports, including cameras in immigration halls.
- No 10 scaled down the scope of the PM’s new “200,000 tests per day” target as the government missed its 100,000 daily tests goal for a fourth day running. The PM’s spokesman said that when Johnson set the new testing target for the end of May during PMQs, he had been referring to testing capacity. Later, Robert Jenrick told the daily press briefing that 69,463 tests were carried out yesterday.
- Rising levels of racism towards people of east Asian heritage have left many feeling too scared to venture out when the lockdown is eventually lifted, research suggests. The survey by Prof Binna Kandola found that just over half of respondents had experienced an increase in discrimination since the pandemic began, with Chinese people reporting being coughed at, attacked, mocked and abused. Kandola said society had an opportunity to show zero tolerance towards racist behaviour once the lockdown is eased.
- The tube will only be able to run at 20% capacity to allow for physical distancing, Sadiq Khan said. The mayor of London said the transport system could not operate at pre-crisis levels while maintaining physical distancing at all times, so capacity would have to be reduced to 13-20% and the carrying capacity of double-decker buses could be reduced from 85 to 15 passengers. He argued that everyone in London who could work from home would have to continue to do so for the foreseeable future.
- And police decided not to take action against Prof Neil Ferguson after he breached lockdown rules. The scientist resigned last night after it emerged that he had broken lockdown restrictions by receiving visits from his lover. This morning the health secretary, Matt Hancock, said it was right that he had stepped down and backed any action the police decided to take. However, Scotland Yard said that since Ferguson had accepted responsibility for his error of judgment, no further action would be taken. Downing Street confirmed Ferguson would no longer be advising the government in any way.
That’s it from us on the UK side for today. Thank you to everybody who got in touch and to all of you for reading along. If you would like to continue following the Guardian’s coronavirus coverage, head over to the global live blog for the worldwide picture.
Updated at 7.10pm BST
6.38pm BST
This is from the statistician David Spiegelhalter.
It all started when the chief medical officer for England, Chris Whitty, praised “an excellent article in today’s Guardian” last week. Boris Johnson also referenced it in today’s PMQs when Keir Starmer asked how we had reached a stage where the UK had the worst coronavirus death toll in Europe.
Updated at 6.41pm BST
6.32pm BST
Robert Jenrick’s press conference – summary
Here are the main points from the press conference.
- Robert Jenrick, the housing secretary, announced the latest daily headline coronavirus death figures. Another 649 deaths have been recorded, taking the UK total to 30,076. These figures cover people who have tested positive for coronavirus and died in any setting (not just in hospital). As this Worldometer chart shows, the UK is the first country in Europe to record more than 30,000 deaths. But the official UK figures do not cover the many people who have died from coronavirus without a test. Jamie Jenkins, a former ONS statistician who has been modelling what the overall figure for excess deaths related to coronavirus might be, says his latest estimate is 54,475.
- Jenrick confirmed that the government has again missed its target on testing. He said 69,463 coronavirus tests were conducted yesterday. That means that for the last four days the government has failed to meet the 100,000 a day target set for the end of April, and for the last three days the number of tests has been falling, not rising. (See 6.04pm.)
- He claimed that councils have had more money from central government so far than they have said they need to meet the costs of coronavirus. Repeatedly stressing his commitment to ensure they get the help they required, he said:
In terms of ensuring that councils get the resources they need, we are absolutely committed to doing that. Councils are receiving more money, so far, than they have reported to us as needing to meet the Covid-related costs that they are bearing.
- He hinted that, as the lockdown starts to ease, the government may reimpose micro lockdowns, in particular areas where coronavirus starts to spread rapidly again. Asked if the lockdown would be lifted in some areas first, he replied:
Our strong preference is that the whole country moves as one.
But if, as we build up our infrastructure for testing and tracking and tracing, in time it is required for us to make interventions in smaller micro communities where you are seeing the virus take hold again, then that will be something that we consider as other countries around the world have done when they have implemented effective track-and-trace systems.
But that is very quite different from making major changes to lockdown measures in one part of the country versus another.
- He said the government did not believe school staff needed PPE. He said:
We’ve taken scientific advice with respect to the level of PPE required in schools. As I understand it, the advice is that staff in non-residential education settings don’t require PPE but we will obviously keep that under close review.
Updated at 6.49pm BST
6.23pm BST
6.19pm BST
The former Tory chancellor George Osborne told BBC Radio 4’s PM he thought tax rises were inevitable amid reports Rishi Sunak is working on plans to “wean” Britain off the furlough scheme.
He said that as the crisis has made Britain poorer, the government would be forced into a choice between reducing public services or increasing taxes, adding:
Yes, you can borrow in the short term and of course, we’re borrowing vast amounts, now. That is not sustainable in the medium term. It’s not a problem for now and it’s not necessarily problem for this year. But ultimately, the government will have to set out a credible fiscal path to try and get the deficit down to stop the debt rising so quickly. And that will have elements of spending constraints and tax increases.
Updated at 6.46pm BST
6.04pm BST
Labour challenges government to explain why testing rate has fallen three days in a row
The Labour party just sent out a press release with this statement from the shadow health secretary, Jonathan Ashworth. He says:
Far from delivering on the promise of 100,000 completed tests a day, testing numbers have now fallen three days in a row.
A test, trace and isolate strategy is crucial to tackling this virus.
Ministers needs to explain why the number of tests being completed daily is falling rather than rising.
5.59pm BST
Q: Will the funding still be available to improve places like Bradford after this is over?
Jenrick says the government remains committed to this agenda.
And that’s it. The press conference is over.
5.57pm BST
Q: Final-year student nurses have not had bursaries. But they are now on the frontline dealing with coronavirus. Is that fair? And would you back a campaign to support this?
Jenrick says the government is very grateful to nursing and midwifery students who have joined the frontline. They will get salaries and pensions appropriate for their level. And their student loans will continue if they have opted to start work early.
5.53pm BST
Q: Sir Patrick Vallance hinted this week that some areas of the country might come out of lockdown sooner. If that were to happen, what help would the police get to deal with the influx of people?
Jenrick says the police are getting the support they need.
Doyle says the contact-tracing process being introduced will ensure that people with symptoms get isolated quickly. This scheme is essential to allow ordinary life to resume.
Updated at 5.55pm BST
5.50pm BST
Q: [From Cornwall Live and the Western Morning News] Hoteliers and others fear they will lose the whole season if they do not reopen by July. What can you do to help?
Jenrick says he understands this. He says measures to help businesses announced by the Treasury have helped. Cornwall council has been one of the best in the country at getting grants out.
He says the PM has said that if further interventions are required to help a sector, the government will consider that.
5.48pm BST
Q: Will PPE be introduced in schools?
Jenrick says the government has taken advice on this. But the advice has been that staff in non-residential settings do not need PPE, he says.
Doyle says getting the confidence of parents and children will be critical.
She says there has been a lot of debate about face masks. They are probably helpful in protecting others if the wearer is infected.
But face masks alone are not enough. Good hygiene is essential.
There are issues like how schools are cleaned, and spacing, to be considered.
She says the government is working intensely on this, and look at what is happening in other countries.
5.45pm BST
On testing, this is from my colleague Anushka Asthana.
5.42pm BST
Q: Might you lift lockdown restrictions later in places like the north-east?
Jenrick says the PM will address this on Sunday.
But the government’s “strong preference” is for the UK to move as one, he says.
However, he suggests that if specific measures were need to prevent a recurrence in particular places, the government might re-impose measures locally.
Updated at 5.43pm BST
5.40pm BST
Here is Labour’s deputy leader, Angela Rayner, on the latest testing figures. (See 5.09pm.)
My colleague Rowena Mason has the full story here:
Updated at 5.42pm BST
5.37pm BST
Jenrick says he thinks the money given to councils so far is sufficient to meet their immediate needs.
But the government will work with them to make sure they have what they need.
He says they should continue to do essential work. And the government will then work with them to understand what the extra costs will be.
5.35pm BST
Q: [From BBC Yorkshire] What is the government doing to make sure that people who need vital operations can get them?
Kanani says in recent months the NHS had to focus on coronavirus, and essential treatments.
But now it is getting back to normal services.
5.33pm BST
Q: [From BBC West Midlands] The PM said councils would get extra help. But it looks as if that won’t be enough. Birmingham council has extra costs of more than £260m. The council says essential services will get cut if they don’t get more help.
Jenrick says the government has promised to give them what they want. It has already committed £3.2bn, he says.
In the West Midlands councils are getting £347m, he says.
If further resources are required, the government will consider this, he says.
Q: But will the extra money get through to each council. A council like Shropshire says it has not had enough. And town councils say the money does not filter down.
Jenrick says the government is committed to helping councils. He says councils have had more money than they need to meet their Covid costs.
5.28pm BST
Jenrick takes a question from Emma from Swansea. She says sport seems to have been prioritised over religion. When will people be free to worship again?
Jenrick says this has been a difficult time for faith groups.
But he says it is right to stick to the medical advice to protect others.
The government is talking to faith leaders about recommencing services when the time is right. But that time is not now, he says.
But he says his department has issued guidance allowing people to hold funerals with small numbers of family members present.
He says it was “not right” that some families were not allowed to attend funerals.
Updated at 5.37pm BST
5.25pm BST
Prof Yvonne Doyle, the medical director of Public Health England, is now presenting the daily slides.
Here is the chart of testing, showing the 100,000 tests per day target has again been missed.
Here is the crude global death comparison slide. This one is shown every day.
And here is the chart showing global comparisons on a per head basis.
(Even on this chart, the UK’s performance is poor. Of the countries featured, only Spain comes out worse.)
Doyle says it takes time to get the figures that allow a fair comparison. She says it may take a year before the data is available.
5.18pm BST
Nikki Kanani, the medical director of NHS England, is speaking now. She says she is a GP.
She says she wants to thank people for following the government advice.
Primary care services are still there for people, she says. There may be more telephone calls or online consultations. But the NHS is still there, she says.
5.16pm BST
Jenrick says this week the government has announced funding to allow councils to help small businesses.
Referring to VE day, he says events will have to be marked at home on Friday.
He recalls speaking to a veteran who said, just as we recovered from the second world war, we will recover again.
5.14pm BST
Jenrick says coronavirus won’t hold back the government’s commitment to levelling up.
He says Boris Johnson will set out on Sunday how the government will move ahead.
Jenrick says his department will help local communities recover.
He says they are looking at how public transport can be made safer.
And they are looking at what can be done to make it easier for people to walk or cycle to work, he says.
5.09pm BST
Official UK coronavirus death toll passes 30,000 as another 649 fatalities recorded
Jenrick is starting now.
He says 69,463 tests were carried out yesterday. That means that for the fourth day in a row the government has missed the target of 100,000 tests per day.
And he says there have been a further 649 deaths, taking the UK total to 30,076.
This figure represents the number of people who have tested positive for coronavirus and who have died. It will be an understatement, because there will also be people who have died from coronavirus without being tested.
Here is the government dashboard with the latest figures.
Updated at 5.15pm BST
5.00pm BST
A millionaire mayor who lives in a stately home and who was criticised for closing his town’s parks amid the pandemic has announced they will be reopened on VE Day.
Andy Preston, who ran a hedge fund and a charity before he was elected as an independent in Middlesbrough, previously said he was right to lock the gates in three major parks, saying the town had been officially found to be the most vulnerable to coronavirus in the country.
But since then, Preston, who owns a grade-II listed mansion with extensive grounds near Northallerton, North Yorkshire, has announced the parks will be opened again from Friday on a trial basis.
The mayor said on Twitter that the time was right to make the change, due to it being VE Day and with the “apparent levelling of infection rates”. He said play areas would remain off limits, but the “beautiful scenery” was open.
The Labour MP for Middlesbrough Andy McDonald had earlier told the Guardian some of the town’s parks could fit within the grounds of the mayor’s mansion, adding:
He can enjoy that, but people living in small terraced houses, they can’t get their lungs breathing in a pleasant environment.
And the local government minister Simon Clarke, the Tory MP for Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland, had written to all councils urging them to keep parks open.
5.00pm BST
UK government’s daily press conference
Robert Jenrick, the housing secretary, is taking the government’s press conference. It is due to start around now. He will be appearing with Prof Yvonne Doyle, the medical director of Public Health England, and Nikki Kanani, the medical director of NHS England.
4.56pm BST
And since we are looking at what academics are saying, this is worth flagging up. It is from Oxford University’s Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine and it presents the latest weekly death figures for England and Wales in the form of what it calls a Florence Nightingale diagram (because she presented data in a similar way). The idea is that presenting death figures in a radial form like this makes it easier to spot variations from the seasonal norm.
Updated at 5.17pm BST
4.54pm BST
Key workers in the frontline battle against Covid-19 should be paid a real living wage, the archbishop of York has told the Lords.
The Rt Rev John Sentamu said the current coronavirus crisis had underlined the need to recognise and value the UK’s key workers, and that paying them at least a real living wage would be a “litmus test” for a fair recovery after the lockdown.
Opening a virtual debate, the archbishop, who chaired the Living Wage Commission, said it was “shocking” that child poverty had not been the number one priority in the “unprecedented package of support” announced by the chancellor. He said:
The coronavirus national emergency is already exposing the inadequacy of the safety net provided by our social security system.
People not previously reliant on the system were now finding how “mean” it was and the crisis would hopefully lead to a more generous and compassionate system, he added.
The real living wage would provide an hourly rate of £9.30 across the UK and £10.75 in London. Sentamu said higher pay would benefit not just workers but businesses and allow the country to “bounce back better” from the pandemic.
4.46pm BST
One of the major unknowns in relation to coronavirus is how many people get the virus but remain asymptomatic. Some new research from the Centre for the Mathematical Modelling of Infectious Diseases (CMMID) at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine suggests that the figure may be much higher than people assume.
The researchers looked at data from the coronavirus outbreak on the Diamond Princess cruise ship, where eventually 80% of passengers and staff were tested. Combining this data with information with data about when people developed symptoms, and modelling showing how the virus would have spread, the team estimated that 72% of people on the ship infected with the virus remained asymptomatic.
The research has not been peer-reviewed, but there is a preliminary outline here, and a press release here. Here’s an extract.
The research team estimated that 72% of people infected with Covid-19 onboard the Diamond Princess cruise ship remained asymptomatic. For each asymptomatic case, it remained uncertain how infectious they were although they were unlikely to be as infectious as a symptomatic case.
Overall, the team estimate that asymptomatic cases were responsible for 11-84% of all infections during the outbreak. Work will be extended with more data (where available) and to other outbreaks, which the team hopes will enable more accurate estimates of the impact of asymptomatic cases on all infections over the coming period.
Rein Houben from the CMMID, who led the research, said:
We know that a substantial number of people infected with the coronavirus are asymptomatic, and there is anecdotal evidence that this group can transmit the virus, However, there are few reliable estimates on the proportion of people with Covid-19 who don’t show symptoms, and their overall contribution to the spread of the virus.
This information is crucial for health policymakers to develop the most effective response strategies, including exiting from lockdowns. Using data from the Diamond Princess cruise ship, we aimed to help fill this knowledge gap.
Updated at 4.54pm BST
4.27pm BST
4.20pm BST
Yesterday Matt Hancock, the health secretary, said that people had a duty to download the new contact-tracing app.
Lord Sumption, the former supreme court justice, told Radio 5 Live’s Emma Barnett earlier that he was fed up of being spoken to like that by Hancock. Sumption explained:
I’m fed up with being told by the health secretary what my duty is. My duty is to comply with the law. And that I will continue to do. As to everything else I will decide for myself if it is a sensible thing to do. And it sounds like it is.
Sumption, who has been critical of the lockdown, said it was time for the government to trust the public. He said:
The government have really got to stop treating the whole of the population as if they were children. Those who… still want a lockdown, can isolate themselves. Let those who don’t, exercise their own common sense and own sense of self-preservation, and get on with their lives. I think this should become voluntary. It would be perfectly possible to make compliance voluntary but to keep closed venues such as restaurants, pubs, theatres, football matches and so on.
Updated at 4.27pm BST
4.20pm BST
In the latest episode of the Politics Weekly podcast, Heather Stewart and Kate Proctor discuss a particularly bad week for Boris Johnson’s government which saw the UK’s death toll surpass 32,000, overtaking Italy as the worst-hit in Europe.
Plus Frances Perraudin reports on how the response of devolved governments in the UK to Covid-19 might affect the future of the union.
4.17pm BST
The rate of increase in confirmed cases of Covid-19 in prisons in England and Wales accelerated in the most recent 24-hour period, data from the Ministry of Justice shows.
As of 5pm on Tuesday, 386 prisoners had tested positive for Covid-19 across 74 prisons, an increase of 7%, while the number of infected prison staff rose by 8% to 433 workers across 67 prisons in the same period.
The number of confirmed cases had been slowly rising by about 1% a day in the last week.
A total of 19 prisoners and six prison staff are known to have contracted Covid-19 and died.
There are 80,100 prisoners in England and Wales and around 33,000 staff in public-sector prisons. Public Health England modelling published last week showed the number of cases and deaths at this point in the pandemic was lower than expected but warned restrictive measures would need to remain until April next year.
The updated figures come as two major penal reform campaigners urge the government not to abandon its early temporary release scheme after documents showed a fraction of those approved for release had been freed.
Updated at 4.28pm BST
4.12pm BST
3.48pm BST
A “much-loved” care home nurse died with coronavirus just days after her granddaughter was born.
Karen Hutton, 58, died at home in the town of Carnoustie, Angus, on 28 April after testing positive for Covid-19. Her only daughter, Lauren, gave birth to a baby girl just two weeks ago, according to care home operators Thistle Healthcare.
She was employed as a staff nurse in the dementia unit at Lochleven Care Home in Broughty Ferry, Dundee. Andrew Chalmers-Gall, manager of Lochleven Care Home, said:
Karen was a tenacious advocate for her residents and she always put their needs first. She was a much-loved friend and colleague, and she’ll be missed terribly by everyone at Lochleven.
3.40pm BST
3.29pm BST
A report commissioned by the judge in charge of the family courts in England and Wales raises severe doubts about the “fairness” of remote video hearings being conducted during the coronavirus crisis.
Carried out by the Nuffield Family Justice Observatory on behalf of Sir Andrew McFarlane, the study says many of those involved found it “extremely difficult to conduct hearings with the level of empathy and humanity” normally required.
More than 930 people responded to the survey including judges, magistrates, barristers, solicitors and parents participating in remote video hearings. Only urgent cases were initially being dealt with by the courts during the lockdown but fear of a massive backlog of cases and the wide availability of online technology created pressure for more online justice.
The report said there were significant concerns raised about the fairness of remote hearings and there were “some worrying descriptions of the way some cases had been conducted”. Concerns related to “where not having face-to-face contact made it difficult to read reactions and communicate in a humane and sensitive way, the difficulty of ensuring a party’s full participation in a remote hearing, and issues of confidentiality and privacy”.
There were also fears about cases involving domestic abuse, parties with a disability or cognitive impairment or where an intermediary or interpreter is required, and concerns were raised about the presence of children during proceedings.
In domestic abuse cases, the report said, “there is a risk that the court process itself may be used as a coercive control tactic and increase feelings of vulnerability. …Some [victims] are distressed by being alone at home during the hearings where they might hear or see the perpetrator.”
The report noted:
Particular concerns were raised by some respondents about urgent applications for interim care orders in relation to newborn babies, with new mothers having to join hearings from hospital, with accompanying difficulties in connectivity and in ensuring any privacy while the hearing was taking place.
3.22pm BST
Some uplifting mid-afternoon news. A father-of-two who spent 19 days in an induced coma in hospital has recovered from coronavirus and returned home in time to celebrate his son’s second birthday.
Omar Taylor, 31, was welcomed home by applause and banners from neighbours after spending six weeks in hospital with Covid-19. He had been intubated, placed in an induced coma at Colchester hospital, and was on a ventilator for 30 days. His wife, Kaitlyn, had been told to prepare for the worst.
After suffering from coronavirus, double pneumonia, sepsis, heart failure and two strokes, he recovered enough to continue his recovery at home. Doctors said he would never walk again, but he left hospital – on foot – in time for his son’s birthday. He is stable but remains critical.
Kaitlyn told the BBC: “He still can’t speak, it’s very hard for us to understand him. But he’s done so well at home. It’s just going to take time.”
The BBC has the story and here is a GoFundMe page set up to support the family.
Updated at 3.34pm BST
3.06pm BST
Beauty firm The Hut Group is utilising its global supply chain to donate 3.5 million items of medical-grade personal protective equipment to the healthcare system in Greater Manchester.
The total shipments include 150,000 face masks, 50,000 disposable masks, 950,000 surgical gloves, 184,000 face shields, 24,000 medical gowns, 500,000 single gloves and 750,000 FFP2 masks.
The mayor of Greater Manchester, Andy Burnham, said:
I’m proud that a Manchester-headquartered global business has used its international contacts and purchasing power to support us in our hour of need to save lives and protect the NHS.
This comes on top of what they’ve already donated to support our frontline staff across Greater Manchester. What a great example of business stepping up to help others.
Updated at 3.11pm BST
2.52pm BST
Further 14 deaths in Northern Ireland, taking total to 418
Another 14 coronavirus deaths have been reported in Northern Ireland, three of which happened in the last 24 hours, bringing the total number of fatalities there to 418, the Department of Health said. A total of 3,934 cases of the virus have been confirmed. The full details are here (pdf).
Updated at 4.10pm BST
2.50pm BST
Discussing the “winding down” of the government’s furloughing scheme on BBC Radio 4’s World at One today, the former Treasury minister David Gauke said that although the scheme seemed to be working, there was a risk people will “get too used to it” as unfreezing the economy is set to take a while. He said:
The challenge is to strike that balance between preventing mass unemployment, which nobody wants, and laying people off from jobs that are completely viable at the end of this process, but on the other hand incurring huge costs to the taxpayers and locking people into doing nothing, when in fact everyone would be better off if they ultimately could go out and move to a different sector, a different employer where they’ve got a sustainable business.
There is a broader risk that we as a society are perhaps insulated from the economic challenges in a way that is a bit of a false position, because in the end you can’t properly be protected from the economic realities and if we don’t recognise that in the end we are going to have to pay our way, we are going to get people back to work, there are long-term risks for the economy.
I don’t think anybody is addicted yet but if over time we end up paying people for staying at home, that’s what they’ll do.
Updated at 3.00pm BST
2.44pm BST
England’s Test cricketers have been told to expect daily temperature checks, regular Covid-19 swabs and possibly nine weeks away from their families under ambitious plans to get the series against West Indies and Pakistan played.
Joe Root’s side had their first briefing about the “bio-secure” measures due to be in place this summer on Tuesday and learned that a squad of up to 30 could be chosen for a run of six Tests at the Ageas Bowl and Old Trafford from 8 July.
While the plan is still fraught with hurdles and subject to guidelines for all sports being approved by central government, there is a growing belief at the England and Wales Cricket Board that the two grounds, with their on-site hotels, could see the risk of playing behind closed doors mitigated to an acceptable level.
Updated at 2.46pm BST
2.38pm BST
No 10 scales down scope of PM’s new ‘200,000 tests per day’ target
The Downing Street lobby briefing has just finished. Here are the main points.
- The prime minister’s spokesman signalled that cabinet and Cobra, the government’s emergency committee, will meet at the weekend to agree the plan to start easing the lockdown. The cabinet will meet, as usual, tomorrow. But the spokesman also said that it was “entirely possible” that cabinet would meet at the weekend. And he indicated that Cobra, the committee that includes representatives of the devolved administrations, would also meet shortly before the announcement gets made by Boris Johnson on Sunday.
- The spokesman refused to comment on reports suggesting that the government may abandon its “Stay home” slogan at the weekend, replacing it with another message consistent with the lockdown starting to ease.
- The spokesman said that, when Boris Johnson set a new testing target in the Commons of 200,000 tests by the end of May (see 12.12pm), the target applied to testing capacity. In the Commons Johnson said:
[Keir Starmer is] right that capacity currently exceeds demand, we’re working on that, we’re running at about 100,000 a day, but the ambition clearly is to get up to 200,000 a day by the end of this month and then to go even higher.
When Matt Hancock set 100,000 a day as a testing target for the end of April, No 10 said that was as target for the actual number of tests carried out, not just capacity (the number of tests that could theoretically be carried out). But the spokesman said the actual target referred to by Johnson at PMQs this afternoon just covered capacity, not actual tests. In recent weeks daily capacity for testing almost always been significantly higher than the number of tests actually carried out. The spokesman said the target also covered antibody testing, which looks at whether people have had the virus, as well as the antigen testing, which looks at whether people have the virus. The current figures only cover antigen testing because a reliable antibody test for use at home is not yet available.
- The spokesman said Prof Neil Ferguson would no longer be advising the government in any way. But he said that others from Imperial College contribute to Sage, the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies. The spokesman said that the government wanted Imperial’s “invaluable work” to continue to be available to it. The spokesman also said that Johnson thought Ferguson had taken the right decision to resign from Sage, and that the social distancing rules were there for a purpose.
- The spokesman dismissed suggestions that Ferguson’s resignation exposed double standards over the social distancing rules. There have been claims that Robert Jenrick, the housing secretary, and Johnson himself have both broken these rules, because Jenrick left London with his family to stay in a home in the country, and Johnson and his fiancee stayed at Chequers after Johnson come out of hospital. The spokesman said that Jenrick was just travelling to rejoin his family, and that Johnson went to Chequers on the advice of his doctors.
- The spokesman said that when Johnson spoke at PMQs about a a “palpable improvement” in care homes, he was referring to death rates falling.
- Jenrick, the housing secretary, will take this afternoon’s press conference, the spokesman said. Prof Yvonne Doyle, the medical director of Public Health England, and Nikki Kanani, the medical director of NHS England, will also be appearing. The questions at the press conference are being allocated to regional newspapers, not national newspapers. The spokesman said this was in recognition of the important role regional papers play.
- The spokesman said more than 69,000 of the new “bounce back” loans were approved when the scheme opened on Monday, worth more than £2bn. He also said 130,000 applications have been now been received, and are being processed.
Updated at 2.42pm BST
2.34pm BST
2.24pm BST
England records another 331 hospital deaths, taking total to 22,049
NHS England has announced 331 new deaths in hospital of people who tested positive for coronavirus, bringing the total number of confirmed reported deaths in hospitals in England to 22,049. The full details are here. The full figures are here (pdf).
Of the 331 new deaths announced today, 54 occurred on May 5, 121 occurred on May 4 and 28 occurred on May 3.
2.12pm BST
Wales records another 21 coronavirus deaths, taking total to 1,044
A further 21 people have died after testing positive for coronavirus in Wales, taking the total number of deaths there to 1,044, Public Health Wales has said. The latest figures are here.
2.05pm BST
In the House of Commons the business minister Paul Scully said that any workers asked to work in an environment they thought was unsafe should contact the health and safety authorities. He was responding to an urgent question tabled by Labour about the potential risk to employees.
Andy McDonald, the shadow employment rights minister, asked the government to publish the guidelines being drawn up for employers to follow when the lockdown starts to relax. Scully told MPs:
This is not a finished process at the moment. What we need to do is get into the technical detail to make sure that everybody has confidence, in the same way that employees need to have confidence. They should be able to discuss with their employers the steps they might take to make their workplace safer themselves, especially when we start to lift restrictions.
Where workers still feel unsafe though, they can contact the Health and Safety Executive or their local authority and where [poor health and safety is uncovered] they can take action.
Updated at 2.13pm BST
1.55pm BST
The EU trade commissioner, Phil Hogan, has warned the UK needs “to get on with the job” if there is to be a deal by the end of the year. Speaking at an Institute of International and Economic Affairs virtual conference, he said:
They need a lot more intensive engagement than we’ve seen in the last few weeks and months. And if we want to achieve the outcome that is preferred by the United Kingdom, to have a deal by the end of the year, we need to get on with the job.
He said the June stock-take by both sides would be “critical” but the UK need to come up with a plan for fisheries, governance and level playing field so they could put it on the negotiating table. He went on:
We’ve been very patient in the European Union and with the United Kingdom in terms of the slow pace that it has shown in relation to engaging with the discussions, and we take account of course of the illness of the prime minister and we hope that he continues to his full recovery.
But I think that the place to do all of this work is at the table of negotiations where there’s been many opportunities, which have not been taken by the United Kingdom in recent weeks, so we hope that in the next two rounds of negotiations, one of which will be next week, that we will see much more intensive work being done much more engagement.
Updated at 2.03pm BST
1.51pm BST
A “careful and cautious approach” to lifting the lockdown is required, the Welsh government’s finance minister, Rebecca Evans, has said.
At her administration’s daily press conference,Evans said the Labour-led Welsh government’s preference remained for a four-nation approach to the easing of lockdown. She said:
We’re keen to move as closely as we can with England at the moment because in Wales we have so many people living on the Wales-England border and it’s important we move in step when we can.
What I expect to see from the prime minister on the weekend is a careful and cautious approach to lifting the lockdown.
Evans called for a “tapered approach” when the furlough scheme winds up. She said:
When it does finally come to an end, as it will inevitably have to do, I think a more tapered approach would be the way to do that.
Updated at 1.52pm BST
1.29pm BST
Here is our story on the Boris Johnson/Keir Starmer exchanges at PMQs. It’s by Rowena Mason and Kate Proctor.
Updated at 1.46pm BST
1.27pm BST
Sir Keir Starmer and other Westminster opposition leaders will be speaking with Boris Johnson about the coronavirus response tomorrow. The Labour leader would raise the need for a “national consensus” on easing the lockdown based around keeping the public safe, a “mass expansion” of contact tracing and protecting key workers, his spokesman said.
Updated at 1.29pm BST
1.23pm BST
A legal challenge has been launched over the way in which do not resuscitate (DNR) orders are being issued during the coronavirus crisis without allegedly sufficient consultation with patients or their families.
Lawyers representing Kate Masters, who brought a case over such orders in 2014, have written to the Department of Health and Social Care warning that the way in which DNRs are made is currently unlawful.
Masters believes that decision-making around DNRs has become “opaque, inconsistent and deficient”. She is concerned about her own position because of her health problems. She says she feels at significant risk of DNR decisions being made without proper process. She said:
I have watched with alarm as reports of blanket DNR orders in care homes and failures to consult with patients and their families have been reported in the news since the start of the coronavirus crisis. After all that my dad did to fight to clarify the law regarding DNRs, I am determined to ensure that my human rights and those of others are not breached due to a lack of government direction.
Merry Varney, her solicitor at the law firm Leigh Day, said:
DNRs imposed in circumstances where patients and their families have no or little information, and no consultation, often lead to a complete breakdown in trust and numerous stories reported in the media show how common it is that patients and families believe these cannot be imposed without consent. Healthcare professionals are already overburdened, our client believes it is time for the government to step up and give national guidance that will ensure consistent and lawful decision-making at a local level and also ensure patients’ fundamental human rights are being upheld.
Updated at 1.27pm BST
1.14pm BST
PMQs – Snap verdict
In a pre-Covid PMQs a Tory prime minister who was riding high in the opinion polls and who was returning to the House of Commons after an illness that left him in intensive care would have been welcomed by such a wall of noise that it would have been hard for any opposition leader to make much of a mark. But, of course, there is no chance of PMQs resuming its shouting match status any time soon (one of the few benefits of this ghastly crisis) and instead Boris Johnson was left looking exposed and diminished as he faced Sir Keir Starmer for the first time.
As had been widely expected, Starmer was impressive – focused, calm, and rational. His interventions today were crisper than in his previous two outings (probably an improvement), and he always ended with a very direct question, simple yet incriminating. No doubt he could manage in a rowdy Commons, but the courtroom silence seems to suit him better, and the overall impression left by the encounter was of a rather floundering prime minister struggling to respond to a full-on grown-up channelling the questions a critical nation wants answering.
Another difficulty for the PM in Zoom PMQs is that he can’t pick the brains of the specialist minister sitting alongside him. Prime ministers are normally more reliant on prompts from colleagues at PMQs than people realise, and Johnson looked particular in need of verbal assistance from Matt Hancock when asked about PPE.
In normal PMQs a struggling PM would resort to sloganising, and hope the backbench noise machine might do the rest, but with that no longer an option it did seem as if Johnson was more reliant on making points of substance. He could not answer Starmer’s questions easily (they were designed to be hard to answer – at least, hard to answer without admitting gross negligence), but he did show some leg on a public inquiry, and provide a relatively revealing answer about why he is making the lockdown announcement on Sunday.
Starmer will be pleased with how the exchanges went. But if the new format militates against sloganising, then that is potentially a problem for the leader of the opposition too. At his first PMQs against Tony Blair, David Cameron came out with the memorable line about how Blair “was the future once” – a soundbite and a slogan, but a good one, that defined Cameron successfully. A week today, we will remember that Starmer looked the part at his first PMQs, but we are less likely to remember what he actually said.
Updated at 4.25pm BST
1.06pm BST
1.00pm BST
The proportion of all Scottish coronavirus deaths happening in care homes rose to 59% last week, up from 52% the week before, adding to the sense of crisis in the sector.
National Records of Scotland, the government agency, said that deaths overall from Covid-19 had declined week on week for the first time since the outbreak began, with 523 deaths relating to the virus recorded in the week ending 3 May (see 12.22.).
That was a fall of 135 from the previous week, with the data including deaths in all settings, including hospitals, homes and other places. There were 310 care home deaths recorded in Scotland last week, compared with 339 the week before.
The NRS said 37% of all Covid-19 deaths last week happened in hospitals compared with 42% the week before. It said three-quarters of all registered deaths so far involved people aged 75 or over, and 52% of the total were male and 48% female.
Pete Whitehouse, the NRS director of statistical services, said:
These latest figures shown that for the first time, since reporting of registered deaths relating to Covid-19 began for week beginning 16 March, there has been a reduction in Covid-19 related deaths from the previous week – down from 658 to 523 Covid-19 related deaths.
Updated at 1.15pm BST
12.58pm BST
Cycling could increase fivefold across London under post-lockdown plans to overhaul the city’s streets, where pavements will be widened to allow for physical distancing and queueing outside shops.
New walking and cycling routes will be constructed along major corridors, including temporary cycle lanes along routes such as Euston Road, under the “London Streetscape” plans. Transport for London (TfL) is also looking at creating temporary cycle lanes on Park Lane.
The release of the initial details by the mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, comes as he continues to come under pressure to increase tube services or take steps to address significant numbers of people still using the network.
Khan’s office said that millions of journeys a day would need to be made by other means, with London’s public transport capacity potentially running at a fifth of pre-crisis levels.
If people switched only a fraction of those journeys to cars, it warned that London risked grinding to a halt, air quality would worsen, and road danger would increase.
The plans were welcomed by organisations such Living Streets, a walking charity, which said the the pandemic had highlighted the importance that walking plays in people’s lives. Its director, Stephen Edwards, said:
Where London’s pavements aren’t suitable for safe social distancing, it is vital widening happens to ensure people aren’t forced into the paths of oncoming traffic.
Updated at 1.13pm BST
12.44pm BST
Scottish government to lift restrictions ‘as soon as possible’ as deaths fall for first time since crisis began
Nicola Sturgeon has told MSPs the Scottish government will start to lift lockdown restrictions “as soon as possible” after the latest data showed overall Covid-19 deaths fell last week for the first time since the crisis began.
The first minister told Holyrood she planned to uphold the current lockdown regulations from tomorrow, when she has to refresh the lockdown orders for the next three weeks, but indicated the new data would spur changes soon.
The progress, while real, is still too fragile to immediately ease restrictions in any significant way but we are planning now for ways in which we can gradually do so, as soon as possible.
She said intensive care cases had again fallen overnight by 15 patients, down to 89, while the number of hospital patients had also fallen by 24 to 1,632.
National Records of Scotland, the government agency, said at noon on Wednesday that deaths overall from Covid-19 had declined week on week for the first time since the outbreak began, with 523 deaths relating to the virus recorded in the week ending 3 May.
A total of 1,703 patients have died in Scotland after testing positive for coronavirus, up by 83 from 1,620 on Tuesday, Sturgeon said. The figures are lower than the 2,795 deaths given earlier by the NRS (see 12.22.) as they do not include suspected and probable coronavirus infections.
The first minister said 12,709 people have now tested positive for the virus in Scotland, up by 272 from 12,437 the day before.
Updated at 1.05pm BST
12.43pm BST
12.36pm BST
Police to take no action over Prof Neil Ferguson’s lockdown breach
Scotland Yard said Prof Ferguson had accepted responsibility for his error so it will not take further action. A statement for the force said:
We remain committed to our role in supporting adherence to government guidance and have made it clear that our starting position is explaining the need to follow the regulations with anyone who is in breach in order to keep people safe and protect the NHS.
It is clear in this case that whilst this behaviour is plainly disappointing, Prof Ferguson has accepted that he made an error of judgment and has taken responsibility for that.
We therefore do not intend to take any further action.
Ferguson, whose scientific modelling was key to the imposition of the UK lockdown, resigned as a government adviser last night after the Telegraph revealed he had flouted lockdown rules by receiving visits from his lover at his home.
Earlier this morning, the health secretary, Matt Hancock, said the scientist’s breach of the rules had left him “speechless”. He said it was right that Ferguson had resigned and that he would back the police in any action they decided to take.
Updated at 1.19pm BST
12.36pm BST
Labour’s Lilian Greenwood asks Johnson to give councils a cast-iron guarantee that they will not lose out from coronavirus.
Johnson says the government has already given billions to councils. And that won’t be the last they get, he says.
And that’s it. PMQs is over.
12.34pm BST
Rob Butler, a Conservative, asks Johnson to support “Bernie the Bus”, a community initiative in his constituency.
Johnson does so, saying he is a supporter of buses.
Updated at 1.18pm BST
12.33pm BST
The SNPs David Linden asks if the goverment will lift the benefits cap.
Johnson says the government is spending an extra £7bn on benefits.
12.33pm BST
Simon Fell, a Conservative, asks if the government supports giving a catch-up premium for schools with disadvantaged pupils, who are likely to have fallen behind.
Johnson says extra computers and laptops have been provided.
And there will be more to come, because this is a government that will pursue our agenda of uniting and levelling up.
Updated at 1.18pm BST
12.31pm BST
The SNP’s Mhairi Black asks if there are any plans to increase the value of employment support allowance.
Johnson says the seven-day waiting time has been removed.
People want a wide programme of support from the government, he says.
12.30pm BST
Ben Bradley, a Conservative, asks about further education. Johnson says the government is going to need this sector badly to provide the skills required for the recovery.
Updated at 12.33pm BST
12.29pm BST
Justin Madders, a Labour MP, asks Johnson if he agrees that it would be wrong for furloughed staff to get laid off.
Johnson says this scheme has been a success. He wants people to be able to go back to work safely and securely.
Updated at 12.30pm BST
12.28pm BST
Rehman Chishti, a Conservative, asks the government to allow small family funerals. It is not fair that they cannot take place while cremations can, he says.
Johnson says he agrees. He wants councils to address this.
12.27pm BST
Johnson says he has no intention of returning to austerity
Labour’s Mike Amesbury asks about his local council. The government said it would compensate councils for spending on coronavirus. But nationally they are short by billlions, he says.
Johnson says the government has “absolutely no intention of returning to the A word [austerity]”.
I can certainly tell him that the government has absolutely no intention of returning to the A-word, which I won’t quote. That is not going to be our approach.
The faster we can suppress the virus, the quicker we can restart the economy, and ensure communities get the help they need, he says.
Updated at 1.33pm BST
12.25pm BST
Heathrow to begin temperature screening of passengers
Heathrow is to begin temperature screening of passengers, several weeks after the measure was deployed by many other major airports around the world.
The airport’s chief executive, John Holland-Kaye, said it would trial technologies and processes which could form the basis of a common international standard for health screening at airports in a bid to encourage passengers to return to flying.
The scheme is aimed at reducing the risk of passengers contracting or transmitting Covid-19 while travelling. The first trial will be launched in the next two weeks and will involve using cameras which are capable of monitoring people’s temperatures.
Cameras will initially be used in the airport’s immigration halls, but could be deployed in areas for departures, connections and airport staff searches.
Temperature screening of passengers has been used by airports in some countries for several weeks as part of measures to tackle the coronavirus pandemic. Holland-Kaye said:
Aviation is the cornerstone of the UK economy, and to restart the economy the government needs to help restart aviation.
The UK has the world’s third-largest aviation sector, offering the platform for the government to take a lead in agreeing a common international standard for aviation health with our main trading partners.
This standard is key to minimising transmission of Covid-19 across borders, and the technology we are trialling at Heathrow could be part of the solution.
Updated at 12.36pm BST
12.23pm BST
Ian Blackford, the SNP leader at Westminster, also mentions the figures showing the UK with the highest death figures for Europe. Some estimates show the numbers could be even higher.
Will the PM follow the best scientific advice in relaxing the lockdown?
Johnson says he will. He says it would be a mistake to introduce measures that would allow a second peak.
Blackford welcomes Johnson’s comment, but says the Scottish secretary, Alister Jack, has been politicising this issue.
Will the PM agree to ensure the devolved administrations agree what is being planned?
Johnson says he wants the widest possible support for what he is announcing.
12.22pm BST
Scotland registers 2,795 deaths with Covid-19 on death certificate
A total of 2,795 people have died in Scotland with confirmed or suspected coronavirus, according to the National Records of Scotland (NRS).
Of these:
– 59% died in care homes
– 37% in hospitals
– 4% in homes or non-institutional settings
The percentage of deaths in care homes has increased for the second week in a row, up from 52% the previous week, but the number of deaths in care homes has gone down from 339 to 310.
There were 523 deaths relating to Covid-19 registered between 27 April and 3 May, a decrease of 135 on those registered between 20-26 April.
The figures are announced weekly and account for all deaths registered in Scotland where Covid-19 was mentioned on the death certificate. They differ from the lab-confirmed coronavirus deaths announced daily by the Scottish government because they include suspected or probable cases of Covid-19.
Updated at 12.40pm BST
12.19pm BST
Johnson says he wants some lockdown easing measures to come into force from Monday
Starmer asks if the PM will come to the Commons on Monday to present his plan.
Johnson says there will be a statement to the Commons on Monday.
(He does not say he will give it.)
He says he wants to introduce some of these measures on Monday. And he says the announcement is on Sunday so he can have the most up-to-date data before taking the final decision.
- Johnson says he wants some lockdown easing measures to come into force from Monday.
UPDATE: Here is the quote from Johnson.
I just want to explain to the house, as a courtesy, why it is happening on Sunday; I am sure that you would be interested to know that, Mr Speaker. The reason is very simple. We have to be sure that the data is going to support our ability to do this, but that data is coming in continuously over the next few days. We will want, if we possibly can, to get going with some of these measures on Monday, and I think it will be a good thing if people have an idea of what is coming the following day.
Updated at 4.23pm BST
12.16pm BST
Starmer says Johnson has admitted there was a capacity problem.
He cites a survey about doctors having to buy their own PPE.
This will get worse when people return to work.
Can the PM assure people they won’t be asked to return to work until a plan is in place?
Johnson says he can.
He says the PPE shortages have been “enraging”.
There have been no national “stock outs” of any PPE item, he says.
- Johnson confirms he will set out details of his plan to start relaxing the lockdown on Sunday.
12.14pm BST
Starmer welcomes the PM’s decision to set a deadline for the 200,000 a day target.
Why was contract tracing abandoned in mid-March?
Johnson says the difficulty in mid-March was that the testing capacity could not meet demand. But now there will be a team in place that can trace hundreds of thousands of cases across the country.
As I think is readily apparent Mr Speaker to everybody who studied the situation and I think as the scientists would confirm, the difficulty in mid-March was that the tracing capacity that we had, that had been useful as he rightly says in the containment phase of the epidemic, that capacity was no longer useful or relevant since the transmission from individuals within the UK meant that it exceeded our capacity then.
Now the value of the testing, tracking and tracing operation that we’re setting up now is that as we come out of the epidemic and as we get the new cases down, we will have a team that will genuinely be able to track and trace hundreds of thousands of people across the country and thereby to drive down the epidemic.
To put it in a nutshell, it is easier to do this now, he says.
Updated at 1.37pm BST
12.12pm BST
Johnson says he wants to reach 200,000 tests a day by end of May
Starmer says the testing numbers have fallen back since last week, when the government hit its 100,000-a-day target.
What was so special about that day?
Johnson says Starmer was right to pay tribute to the work done on this last week.
He says the ambition is to get testing up to 200,000 a day by the end of this month, and then go even higher.
Updated at 1.21pm BST
12.10pm BST
Starmer says the government publishes comparative death figures every day. So it can’t argue they don’t count.
He says the government has been too late on issues like testing and PPE.
Why has it taken so long to improve the situation in care homes?
Johnson says there has been a “palpable improvement” in care homes.
Updated at 1.22pm BST
12.09pm BST
Johnson hints that public inquiry will have to take place
Sir Keir Starmer starts by saying it is good to see the PM back in his place.
Last week the PM talks about the “apparent success” of the government’s approach. But death numbers are the highest in Europe, and the second highest in the world. That’s not a success.
How on earth did it come to this?
Johnson cites what Prof David Spiegelhalter wrote about comparing death rates in a Guardian article.
He says of course there will be a time to look at what went wrong.
- Johnson hints that public inquiry will have to take place.
Updated at 1.22pm BST
12.06pm BST
Johnson says the government is supporting tourism in Devon. The priority is to suppress this disease, he says. He says that will help tourism everywhere.
12.05pm BST
Boris Johnson starts by paying tribute to the 107 NHS workers and 29 care workers who have died.
And he pays tribute to the staff who looked after him at St Thomas’ hospital.
Updated at 1.23pm BST
12.04pm BST
Sir Lindsay Hoyle, the Speaker, opens PMQs by talking about VE day on Friday. There will be a wreath-laying ceremony in the Commons, he says.
And he says the whole country will welcome Boris Johnson back.
12.01pm BST
These are from the Spectator’s James Forsyth.
12.00pm BST
From the Labour adviser Damian McBride
11.58am BST
Here is the “call list” (pdf) of MPs down to ask a question at PMQs.
11.57am BST
A businesswoman has told the PA news agency she is too scared to return to work when lockdown measures are eased after being spat on during her commute.
Jenny Pattinson, who is mixed race, said she was shaken and angry after the incident, which police were unable to investigate further as the CCTV footage had been overwritten.
The 41-year-old, from Ascot, Berkshire, now does not feel safe in public without her husband, and will continue to work from home for a while once the lockdown is lifted. She told PA that racist behaviour and comments are “just a day-to-day reality for Chinese people and the pandemic has made it a lot worse”. She said:
It’s escalated, it’s immediately more threatening.
I’m a professional woman, I’m 41 years old, I work in the City of London. I’ve worked hard to get to where I’ve got to, I was born here.
But I feel scared now. Even if lockdown lifts, I’m not going to be going back to work straight away because I feel quite scared without being with my husband, to be honest with you.
And that’s a feeling I have not experienced since when I used to get bullied at school, racist bullying when I was a kid, feeling that scared.
Pattinson, whose has a Chinese mother and Scottish father, said she had also noticed other commuters avoiding her on the train before lockdown was imposed.
Her mother, who is in her 70s, was sworn at and called “filthy” on a flight in March, while her cousin, a frontline hospital worker, has also received abuse.
Asked what she thinks will happen when lockdown measures are eased, she said:
I think it’ll be much worse. I’ve seen what’s on social media as well, the vitriol. Sometimes people have commented on news articles that are reporting about this virus, and just the amount of racism, the level of racism, the amount of stereotyping that’s going on is absolutely horrific.
Just seeing those things just make me feel more concerned and more worried and more scared actually, for myself and for my family members and friends.
Pattinson said it is sad that there has been no high-level condemnation from the UK government, especially after comments from the US president Donald Trump about Covid-19 being a “Chinese virus”. She urged Boris Johnson to speak out, adding:
I think there needs to be somebody standing up and saying this isn’t right.
Updated at 11.57am BST
11.57am BST
PMQs
PMQs is about to start.
It will be the first time Boris Johnson has faced Sir Keir Starmer across the dispatch box.
Updated at 1.23pm BST
11.53am BST
Tube trains in London will only be able to run at 20% capacity at most under social distancing, Khan says
In an article for City AM, the mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, has said that if social distancing rules remain in place, tube trains in the capital will only be able to run at 20% normal capacity, at most. And double decker buses could end up carrying just 15 passengers, he says.
Here is an extract.
It’s an inescapable fact that no mass transport system of the scale we have in London can operate at full capacity while maintaining social distancing at all times. Even with Tube ridership standing at just five per cent at the moment, there are times when passengers struggle to keep their distance.
This means that if the social distancing requirements remain in place, the total carrying capacity of the Tube will have to be reduced to between 13 to 20 per cent of pre-crisis levels – even with close to 100 per cent of trains running. We will also need to have a fundamentally different approach to operating stations, with strict queuing systems to limit the number of people who can access the network at any one time. Certain major stations where TfL and National Rail services interchange are likely to present the biggest challenge.
Likewise, there will need to be big changes to how we run the bus network. The carrying capacity of double decker buses could be reduced from 85 passengers to just 15. During the lockdown, we have been encouraging social distance queuing at some of our 21,500 bus stops by putting markings on the pavement. But this system will not be possible to maintain when passenger numbers start to increase. We are looking at possible solutions and have already started working with London boroughs to widen pavement space in key locations to alleviate the pressure. However, it will still be impossible to maintain social distance if passenger numbers increase even modestly.
One consequence of this, Khan argues, is that in London “everyone who can work from home will have to be told to continue to do so for the foreseeable future.”
11.42am BST
Chinese in Britain ‘too scared to venture out alone’ amid rising levels of anti-Asian racism
Rising levels of racist abuse that forced people of Chinese heritage to withdraw from UK society before the lockdown are likely to escalate when it lifts, an academic has warned.
Chinese people have been coughed at, attacked and told to “go back home”, according to research led by Prof Binna Kandola. Reported experiences ranged from casual jokes to violent attacks and death threats, with people left too frightened to venture out alone and children ridiculed by their peers, 29 in-depth interviews with people of east Asian heritage revealed.
Kandola told the PA news agency that some people who have lived in the UK their whole life are questioning “whether people of Chinese heritage will ever be accepted as British”.
Just over half of the 412 people surveyed said they had experienced an increase in discrimination during the Covid-19 outbreak. Three in 10 said they had witnessed or experienced discrimination at work, while 37% said they had experienced this outside the office.
One woman, an NHS doctor who works in her local hospital’s respiratory unit, said she has stopped her daily morning jog because of the abuse. Another family withdrew their four-year-old boy from a football club after other parents told their children not to stand close to him. One respondent told Kandola:
Nearly every British-born Chinese person I’ve spoken to is genuinely very shocked about what has happened. They are British, have lived all their lives in Britain and yet they feel like outsiders now.
Prof Kandola said society has an opportunity to show zero tolerance towards racist behaviour when the UK eases lockdown measures. Condemnation from leading politicians and the media would help those affected feel like they are being listened to, he said, while also suggesting local authorities direct victims of abuse to helplines or support groups. He said:
There’s a role for all of us to keep our eyes and ears open about what is going on around us and, when we see it, to intervene.
We are actually better than this. As a nation we are better than this.
And there are a lot of people in this country who will be shocked about what is going on, and will do something about it.
Updated at 11.53am BST
11.34am BST
Updated at 11.45am BST
11.29am BST
Hancock’s Q&A on Sky News – Summary
Here are some more lines from Matt Hancock’s Q&A on Sky News. I have already posted on what he said about Prof Neil Ferguson. (See 10.33am.)
- Hancock refused to accept figures suggesting the UK has the highest death rate from coronavirus in Europe. Asked about this data, Hancock said:
I think we’ve got to be very cautious with these data. I think we’ve got to be really careful in how we describe it, because you’ve got to take a lot of things into account.
Firstly, we are one of the biggest countries in Europe and that matters, so there are smaller countries which naturally will have a lower death rate because they have got fewer people.
Spain and Italy, for instance, don’t include deaths outside hospital in their figures. We didn’t used to, because it is harder to count deaths in the community and in care homes, and we now do …
If you talk to the statisticians and the chief medical officer, what they say is it’s only afterwards, looking back and looking at the total number who have died during the peak, compared to the normal number – because you’ve also got to take into account the age profile, factors like obesity.
What Hancock is saying about Italy contracts what No 10 said in a caption to one of the slides shown at the daily press conference on 29 April. That said the Italian figure did include care home deaths.
- Hancock said that the restrictions imposed on the 1.5 million “clinically extremely vulnerable” people who have been told to stay at home for 12 weeks could be eased, even without a vaccine. Asked about this group, he said:
We may well be able to release some of those measures before a vaccine is available if we can get the number of new cases right down.
If we succeed in doing that we will be able to take clinical advice on whether it is safe for those who are shielded to, for instance, to hug their grandchildren. That is right at the front of my mind.
- He suggested that cafes may be able to open for customers sitting outside relatively soon. Asked by a viewer who wanted to know when their cafe could open, he replied:
The business secretary is working on the rules for safe working so, when we get the rate of new infections down, we can work on how people can get back to work as safely as possible. And we are going to say more about that very shortly.
There is strong evidence that outdoors the spread is much, much lower, so there may be workarounds that some businesses, for instance cafes, especially over the summer, may be able to put into place.
- He said it would too soon to say when schools would be allowed to open. Asked about this, he said:
We don’t know. We don’t know because we have to see the progress of the disease and we don’t know how people are going to behave in terms of the lockdown measures which are the thing that have the biggest impact on getting the disease down.
I understand the frustration of people wanting to know the answer – will it be June, will it be September, for what age groups? We just don’t yet have the data but I think we are coming to a position relatively soon.
- Hancock said the government could have explained the help available to care homes more effectively. Asked about problems with testing for people in care homes, Hancock said the government had to build the capacity for those tests to take place. Asked what he could have done differently, he said:
I think it’s very hard. I feel like we’ve put a huge amount of effort and resources behind supporting care homes from the start, maybe we should have explained that more clearly.
- He claimed the UK was now a world leader on testing. He said:
We invented the test in January. In February we got the number of tests up to 2,000 [a day]. In March we multiplied that by five times to 10,000. Then we set the 100,000 target.
The Germans started with this enormous diagnostics industry. But if you look at other countries around the world we are miles ahead on testing and we are now one of the world leaders.
It is true that Germany has a very high capacity – about the same as ours. So we have basically caught up with Germany that started with this massive capability. We are miles ahead of South Korea now. Absolutely.
- He said that he had not seen any evidence to support President Trump’s claim that coronavirus was likely to have originated in a Chinese laboratory.
- Hancock refused to give himself 10 out of 10 for his handling of the crisis.
Updated at 11.50am BST
11.26am BST
Strictly Come Dancing judge Craig Revel Horwood has said the programme’s producers have “contingency plans” to help ensure this year’s series can go ahead despite the coronavirus disruption.
He told ITV’s Lorraine that he has his “fingers crossed” that it can go ahead, adding that there are “ways about it” that could mean the programme does not have to be cancelled.
Revel Horwood noted that not all routines “mean you are dancing together” and couples could “remain two metres apart or whatever the rules might be at the time”.
A socially distanced series “could become something really quite special”, he said.
He added that the BBC “do not want to let the people down” and that he is “pretty much on board” that the series is going to happen.
10.44am BST
At least two people a day have been using a free train travel scheme to escape domestic abuse during the coronavirus lockdown, figures reveal.
A total of 53 people have used the Rail to Refuge scheme since 9 April, which offers free train travel to a safe refuge, the Rail Delivery Group said.
More than half of people who booked through Rail to Refuge said they would not have travelled if the journey was not paid for, the RDG said.
The scheme launched in September last year on Southeastern services and in March, GWR joined. It was extended to all train companies on 9 April amid warnings the pandemic was triggering a surge in domestic abuse cases.
Southeastern recorded just seven uses of the scheme between September and 9 April so the take-up during the lockdown suggests an increase in demand.
Nicki Norman, the acting chief executive of Women’s Aid, said:
Accessing money can be difficult for women experiencing domestic abuse, particularly if they are experiencing financial abuse. We know that this can stop women from travelling to safety and can be a huge barrier to support. We’re delighted that our Rail to Refuge scheme is removing this barrier and is allowing women to travel to the safety of a refuge without the difficulty, and sometimes impossibility, of booking and paying for their own travel.
Updated at 11.51am BST
10.41am BST
Dozens of drug policy experts in the UK have urged the home secretary to enact laws which were amended last week to allow more flexible access to controlled medications during the pandemic.
The Royal College of GP’s has warned that Covid patients are experiencing “unnecessary” pain and distress in the final days and hours of their life due to strict bureaucratic hurdles governing the supply of controlled drugs such as morphine for which named prescriptions are required for its use.
In a letter, about 50 prominent experts and campaigners called for the recent changes to laws controlling prescribable drugs to be put into place without delay. Ian Hamilton, an expert in addiction and mental health from the University of York, who organised the letter, said:
It is encouraging to see the Department of Health recognise the need to provide flexible arrangements for the supply and use of controlled drugs during the Covid pandemic. This is long overdue as some of the regulations place onerous restrictions on health care staff and pharmacists who are already stretched.
The re-use of medicine like morphine is a sensible and pragmatic move which will not only be welcomed by health care workers but has the potential to ensure unnecessary suffering is avoided, as patients who are in pain or experience severe breathlessness can be treated in a timely and safe way.
The call comes after the home secretary Priti Patel wrote to the Advisory Council for the Misuse of Drugs saying: “I must be clear that these measures will not come into use with immediate effect. The government, in close liaison with the NHS service and devolved administrations, will carefully consider when to ‘switch on’ these measures.”
It is understood that the new flexibilities introduced by the Home Office would only be used if demand and workforce pressures during the pandemic put local health services at imminent risk of failing to fulfil their role or in the event of a serious national shortage of a specified controlled drug.
10.34am BST
Rory Stewart quits campaign to become London’s mayor
Rory Stewart has abandoned his bid to become London mayor, saying that campaigning has become impossible after the election was delayed due to the coronavirus crisis. The former Tory cabinet minister said it had been an “agonising decision” but it was unfair on the unpaid volunteers working on his campaign.
10.33am BST
Hancock suggests Prof Ferguson’s lockdown breach could be matter for police
Matt Hancock, the health secretary, has just started taking part in a Q&A on Sky News. And he started by escalating the criticism of Prof Neil Ferguson, suggesting there could be a case for the police getting involved.
Asked by the presenter Kay Burley if Ferguson should be prosecuted for breaking the lockdown rules, Hancock replied:
You can imagine what my views are.
It’s a matter for the police. As a government minister, I’m not allowed to get involved in the operational decisions of police matters. But I think that the social distancing rules are very important and should be followed.
Burley said that Dr Catherine Calderwood, the Scottish chief medical officer who resigned after it emerged she had visited her second home, had been issued with a warning by the police. Asked if he approved of what the police did in that situation, Hancock said:
Absolutely I back the police. I back the Scottish police, I would back the police here. They will take their decisions independently from ministers, that’s quite right. It’s always been like that.
And that’s why, even though I’ve got a view as to what I think, as a minister the way we run the police is that they make their decisions like this. So I give them their space to make that decision. But I think he took the right decision to resign.
Hancock also said he was speechless when he heard what Ferguson had done. In his statement to the Daily Telegraph, which broke the story, Ferguson justified his decision to meet a lover who lived in another household on the grounds that he was acting on the basis that he was immune, because he had had coronavirus. But Hancock said that he had also had coronavirus and that he has specifically asked the chief medical officer if that meant he was at lower risk. Hancock said he had been told he still had to observe the social distancing rules.
Hancock could easily have dodged Burley’s questions about police involvement, but he chose to answer in a way that clearly implied this was a case where the police might want to get involved.
However, in doing so, Hancock also suggested he is not fully familiar with the regulations imposing the lockdown rules on England – the Health Protection (Coronavirus, Restrictions) (England) Regulations 2020, which Hancock himself introduced. These say that during the emergency period “no person may leave the place where they are living without reasonable excuse”.
But, according to the Telegraph story, Ferguson did not leave him house to see his lover. She came to visit him. There might be grounds for saying that she has broken the regulations, but not Ferguson.
Updated at 11.24am BST
10.05am BST
Yesterday Downing Street told us that Boris Johnson has started taking a daily walk around St James’s Park as part of his lockdown exercise regime. Perhaps it is just a ploy to get out of changing nappies? But it suits the photographers, and here are some pictures from today.
And here he is with a dog in shot (but not his own, which doesn’t seem to get invited out on the daily walk).
9.34am BST
Good morning. I’m Andrew Sparrow, joining the blog for the day.
Here are the main items on the agenda.
9.30am: Executives from Heathrow, ABTA, the travel association, and the Airport Operators Association are among those giving evidence to the Commons transport committee.
10am: Matt Hancock, the health secretary, takes part in a Q&A on Sky News.
12pm: Boris Johnson faces Sir Keir Starmer at PMQs. It will be the first time the two men have gone head to head in the Commons as party leaders.
12.30pm: The Scottish and Welsh governments are due to hold their daily briefings.
After 12.30pm: Alok Sharma, the business secretary, answers an urgent Commons question on workplace safety when the lockdown gets lifted.
1.30pm: Downing Street holds its lobby briefing.
5pm: The UK government is due to hold its daily briefing.
Updated at 10.28am BST
9.29am BST
Ocado is continuing to profit from the Covid-19 pandemic. This morning it has reported a 40% surge in UK revenue so far this quarter, up from 10% growth in the first three months of 2020.
Demand surged as the lockdown began, creating an “unprecedented” level of demand from customers keen to avoid venturing to the shops.
It says:
Growth in retail revenue in the second quarter to date is 40.4% up on last year, compared to 10.3% growth in the first quarter.
The number of items per basket appears to have passed its peak but remains high, as more normal shopping behaviours have returned, and the share of fresh and chilled products in the mix, relative to ambient, is also returning to normal.
For all business updates, do visit business live:
Updated at 10.34am BST
9.00am BST
Theresa May warns ‘populist politics’ hindering global cooperation against coronavirus
The former prime minister Theresa May has criticised the global response to coronavirus, accusing world leaders of failing “to forge a coherent international response”.
In an article in the Times that will be seen as implicit criticism of President Trump’s administration in particular, she warned that lack of cooperation could lead to the world becoming more dangerous.
Against a backdrop of populist politics in many countries, the search for political solutions to economic and social challenges has become a competition of absolutes. A polarised politics has taken hold. It views the world through a prism of winners and losers and sees compromise and co-operation as signs of weakness. Lost is the idea that countries do better by working together to solve common problems, even if doing so sometimes means an apparent sacrifice of short-term benefit for the greater good. In its place is a cynical calculus: “I’m right and you’re either with me or against me.” This is the world that the pandemic hit.
A highly infectious novel virus, life-threatening for many, might seem to be just the sort of thing countries would want to work together on. Instead, it has been treated as a national issue for countries to deal with alone. Researchers and scientists may work together across the world but there is little evidence of politicians doing so …
There remains no collective international view as to what works best in dealing with the virus — nor does there seem to have been any attempt to form one. This risks exacerbating the shift towards nationalism and absolutism which is emasculating the institutions that served us well over decades. A world in which a few “strong men” square up to each other and expect everyone else to choose between them would be a dangerous one.
Updated at 9.20am BST
8.53am BST
Minister hints there will be inquiry into coronavirus, saying all governments will need to learn lessons
James Brokenshire has also been speaking on BBC Breakfast, and pushed on the UK’s death toll, which is now the highest in Europe, Brokenshire said after the pandemic there will be a chance to see “what mistakes have been made”.
He told BBC Breakfast:
It is an absolute tragedy for anyone to lose a loved one. And there will be, I’m sure, plenty of reflection and time once we are through this terrible virus to be able to look at actions that have been taken and to see what lessons can be learned, what mistakes have been made. And every government I think will need to do that and we are no exception to that.
The government has not yet confirmed that there will be a public inquiry into its handling of the coronavirus crisis once it is over, but Brokenshire’s words may be the closest any minister has come to saying it’s inevitable.
Asked the government’s lockdown plans, Brokenshire said there is likely to be a “careful”, “cautious and thoughtful” approach:
It does need to be done with that great care and thought, because the last thing that we need is another second surge, for the NHS to be overwhelmed and all of the issues that that would bring.
Pushed on testing, Brokenshire said the government decided to stop testing and tracing for coronavirus in the community on March 12 due to a “shift” in expert advice. He said:
We’ve always been informed by the expert advice in this. There was a shift in terms of how testing was done – we’ve already heard about some of the issues of overall capacity at that point of time and some of the evidence that (Sir) Patrick Vallance, our chief scientific officer (sic), has given.
Asked whether, had there been the capacity, track-and-tracing should have continued, the Home Office minister said:
Would there have been benefit in having that extra capacity, as Patrick Vallance highlighted in his evidence yesterday? Yes.
The challenge that we had was that we have some fantastic laboratories, some fantastic expertise, but it has been the capacity restraints that we have had, and therefore that has posed challenges, but also that has now been ramped up to go from 2,000 tests (per day) in February to 120,000 at the end of April.
Reminder: this is what the UK’s chief scientific adviser Sir Patrick Vallance told the Commons Health Select Committee yesterday:
I think that probably we, in the early phases, and I’ve said this before, I think if we’d managed to ramp testing capacity quicker it would have been beneficial.
And, you know, for all sorts of reasons that didn’t happen.
I think it’s clear you need lots of testing for this [but] it’s completely wrong to think of testing as the answer.
It’s just part of the system that you need to get right. The entire system needs to work properly.
Brokenshire defended the decision not to close UK borders in a bid to stop the virus spreading across the country, after Vallance said most of the coronavirus strains being spread across the UK in March came from people returning from Spain and Italy. Brokenshire said:
I think it is important to note that the scientific advice was very clear that, up to this point in time, placing restrictions at the border would not have had any significant impact on epidemic progression in the UK.
Sage looked at this on March 23 – the numbers coming from other countries were estimated to be insignificant compared with domestic cases, comprising around 0.5% of total cases at the time.
Since then, obviously, you’ll be more than aware, with all of the issues in the aviation sector, how we’ve seen a reduction in air passengers by around 99% since the start of the outbreak.
It is something we will continue to keep under review as we look to the next phase but, at that time, the advice was clear that placing restrictions would not have had any significant impact.
Updated at 9.51am BST
8.45am BST
Prof Ferguson right to step down, says minister
Security Minister James Brokenshire has called Prof Neil Ferguson’s resignation a “matter of regret” but an “appropriate course” of action. Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, he said:
I’m obviously saddened to hear this development and the actions Professor Ferguson has taken but, ultimately, I think it is the right course of action.
I think Professor Ferguson has taken an appropriate course given the issues of ensuring there is clarity of message on upholding the rules and requirements on social distancing and just why that matters so much in terms of protecting our NHS and saving lives.
It is a matter of regret but that guidance is unequivocal, it is there to protect all of us.
Asked about reports that care home residents and staff are not being tested to determine if they are asymptomatic Covid-19 sufferers, Brokenshire said the government was working with the care sector on testing. He said:
We are still very firmly discussing with the sector, with Public Health England and reaching out to ensure that capacity is reaching where it needs to be.
That work still continues. We are obviously concerned about issues in care homes, ensuring there is that reach – it is there in terms of the capacity, having gone up – and how we ensure we can get that further, where it is needed, given the whole point of investing in that was to ensure that it can give that sense of reassurance.
Updated at 9.44am BST
8.25am BST
Will coronavirus spell the end of the party for Ibiza?
8.14am BST
My colleague Steven Morris has this report on the name change of the national assembly of Wales:
There will be no fanfare and little ceremony but the body formerly known as the national assembly of Wales has a new name.
From now it will be known as Senedd Cymru – the Welsh parliament. It is expected that the rather bulky title will be commonly shortened to “the senedd”.
The first minister, Mark Drakeford, said the new name would send out a message that it was a “full-blown primary law-making institution”.
Also changing are the titles of the 60 elected members. They are now members of the senedd (MSs) as opposed to assembly members (AMs). Or aelod o’r senedd (AS) in Welsh.
Other changes introduced today include 16 and 17-year-olds having the right to vote in senedd elections.
Drakeford said:
I think it’s important to send a message out to people in Wales that an institution which began with very modest powers has over 20 years developed into a full-blown primary law-making institution with far deeper powers and wider powers as well.
The first minister said the immediate priorities for the senedd would be continuing to shape the laws governing the coronavirus lockdown.
The name change has not been without controversy – many champions of the Welsh language have argued the new name should be Welsh only.
Updated at 8.45am BST
7.58am BST
This interview with Ellie Orton, the chief executive of NHS Charities Together (NHSCT), by the Guardian’s David Brindle is fascinating.
As a result of the Herculean fundraising efforts of Captain Tom Moore the charity has been propelled into the limelight. Orton says:
In terms of income, the profile and the understanding of NHS trusts and boards that charity could be a key partner – well, instead of accomplishing that in five years as we had hoped under our strategic plan, it’s pretty much been done in five weeks.
But it is this paragraph that stands out:
While [NHGS charities] all stress that they are supplementing taxpayer funding, and paying for extras rather than for basics such as personal protective equipment (PPE) for health workers or ventilators for patients during the current crisis, the ground rules are not as clear as is commonly supposed. An official review in 2012 concluded that “there is no hard and fast rule that charities must not subsidise or replace public services”.
Read the full story here:
Updated at 9.42am BST
7.48am BST
Shadow health secretary Jonathan Ashworth has been speaking on BBC Breakfast this morning.
Ashworth said the government needs to have a plan which should include more targeted testing and tracing to tackle the disproportionate number of deaths in poorer areas.
He told BBC Breakfast:
My worry is that Covid-19 is going to make these health inequalities in society even worse so I’m calling on the government to have a plan to tackle these health inequalities so we don’t see this widening gap in life chances and health outcomes.
Asked about the coronavirus app, which began a trial on the Isle of Wight on Tuesday, Ashworth said he will download it but urged the government to mobilise local experts “on the ground”. He said:
I will be downloading it because we want to see it succeed, although we’ve got questions about whether it will succeed, whether privacy issues have been resolved.
But I actually think to really successfully deliver the tracing service, we need boots on the ground, we need local government public health experts, you need your environmental health experts, we need to use our expertise in local primary care services because this is a very labour intensive job and they’ve got experience.
Updated at 9.05am BST
7.27am BST
Government looking to close wage-subsidy scheme
The chancellor, Rishi Sunak, is preparing to wind down the coronavirus wage-subsidy scheme for workers in the UK from July as part of government plans to gradually remove lockdown measures, reports my colleague Richard Partington.
With almost a quarter of employees in Britain furloughed in the past fortnight, the chancellor is expected to announce that the Covid-19 job retention scheme will be steadily scaled back as restrictions on business activity are lifted.
The Treasury is understood to be examining several options for tapering the scheme, including cutting the 80% wage subsidy paid by the state to 60% and lowering the £2,500 cap on monthly payments. Another option promoted by employers’ groups to allow furloughed staff to work, but with a smaller state subsidy, is also under consideration.
Sources indicated that a final decision has yet to be made, but the Treasury was working closely with No 10 as Boris Johnson prepares to outline plans on Sunday to gradually lift lockdown restrictions. After more than a month of tight controls on social and business activity across Britain and in other countries around the world, the UK is on the brink of the deepest recession in living memory.
Read the full story here:
A very good morning to all UK readers coming to the liveblog this morning. As ever we really value your tips and comments, so please do get in touch. I’m on alexandra.topping@theguardian.com and @lexytopping on Twitter. My DMs are open.
7.27am BST
Here is a round up of the biggest stories we have today:
- Britain has the worst coronavirus death toll in Europe, official figures showed on Tuesday, prompting calls for an inquiry into the handling of the pandemic. The government’s tally of fatalities across the UK reached 29,427 for those who tested positive for coronavirus, exceeding the 29,029 recorded in Italy – until now Europe’s worst-hit country. Italy’s total does not include suspected cases.
- Britain could exit the coronavirus lockdown by relaxing restrictions on more than half of the population and beefing up protection for those over 70 and vulnerable people, scientists have said.
- Prof Neil Ferguson, the epidemiologist whose modelling helped shape Britain’s coronavirus lockdown strategy, has quit as a government adviser after flouting the rules by receiving visits from his lover at his home.
- Youth unemployment in Britain will reach the 1 million mark over the coming year unless the government provides job guarantees or incentives for school leavers and graduates to stay on in education, a thinktank warns. The Resolution Foundation (RF) said that in the absence of action an extra 600,000 people under the age of 25 would swell dole queues, with a risk of long-term damage to their career and pay prospects.
guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010
Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.